DIGITAL CAMRA
The On-line version of the Cornwall CAMRA Branch Newsletter
ONE & ALE

March-April 2005 (archived)


For details of the Real Ale and Pie Festival this weekend (29 Apr-1 May) at the Smugglers' Den, Trebellan go to their website at http://www.thesmugglersden.co.uk/festival.htm  Free transport details can be found at:
 
Pubs Diary

News Headlines

Unhappy with Short Measure? - You're Barred!  Pub chain bans protesting regular

CAMRA Launches New Pub Viability Test - Guide for planners when a pub is threatened with closure

Bert Dies - Well-known CAMRA supporter is sadly lost

Cornish Pub News - Frequently updated - keep up with the pub changes (if you can)

Cornish Brewery News - Update on the local brewers

Pubs Diary - a service for our publicans

Cornish Ale Guide On Sale - Local guide to Real Ale in Cornwall


Pensioner Barred for Complaining of Short Measure

A regular drinker at J D Wetherspoon's pub in Falmouth, the Packet Station, was naturally indignant when he was served a pint consisting of a significant amount of froth, and asked for it to be topped up.  Mr Alan Tweddle, 71, was even more indignant at being ignored when he had to ask a couple more times for a top-up to the amount he felt he had paid for.  Eventually, he got his top up but served with such bad grace that he drank his beer and left.

Once home, he did what most punters don't do (and perhaps should more often): he wrote a letter of complaint to the JDW head office in Watford.  "I didn't send them a nasty letter, I was not abusive or abrasive," said Mr Tweddle, "but I did say it was among the worst pubs in the country for service".

In her letter of reply, Wetherspoon's customer services coordinator Paula Spencer admitted that the customer is entitled to a top up if they are given short measure.  However, having apologised to Mr. Tweddle for the poor service he experienced, the letter went on to say that following discussions with the management of the Packet Station, 'they advise me that at present they do not wish you to return to the pub.  They are the licensee of the premises', the letter continued, 'and it is not a requirement of the liquor licence that the licensee has to provide you with a reason for barring you'.  A Wetherspoon spokesman added that he couldn't go into the details of the ban because he didn't know them, but 'we always back up our management in incidents like this'.

Mr. Tweddle, who also passed the Wetherspoon letter to local  CAMRA members, has been a regular at the Packet Station since it opened two years ago, calling in there on Mondays, Thursdays and Saturdays and spending over the 3 days, by his estimate, "at least £30".

This is an interesting development in a national pub chain that prides itself on the standard of service it offers to beer drinkers all over the UK.  Ironic that it should choose this moment to place itself firmly on the wrong side of CAMRA, which is currently promoting a new campaign to ensure that if you pay for a pint, then you can expect a pint (picture, right).


Top of Page Next story

CAMRA Launches new Pub Viability Test

As a National Pubs Week initiative at the end of February, CAMRA nationally launched a new 'Public House Viability Test' to help save Britain's public houses.  The test provides guidelines to assist Local Authorities and local communities in determining the viability of a pub threatened by closure.  An early version of the test was launched 5 years ago, but proved so useful to planning authorities, government inspectors and others that a completely revised version has been produced, building on and refreshing the original.

Nationally, some 5 or 6 pubs are lost to the community for ever each week, on average.  Some of them are basket cases, of course, and no amount of dedication could ever make them viable.  But many - too many, we feel - are declared 'unviable' by landlords or developers who want to close the premises and turn them into dwellings or other profitable cash cows.  

We in Cornwall are not immune; in recent years we have lost several pubs, among the most recent being the old Mount's Bay Inn in Penzance (now an Indian restaurant), the Admiral Nelson in Falmouth (for property development which seems to have stalled - and in Nelson's Trafalgar anniversary year if you please!), and the Treetops Inn, Cubert (for landlord's residence).  In the first case, the Mount's Bay was allowed to run down by an uninterested landlord who did little to encourage his locals or anyone else.  The Admiral Nelson was deliberately run down to allow it to look so seedy outside that nobody who didn't know the place would be tempted in.  And the third relies on the fact that there's nothing to stop you closing your pub - but you can't change it into a house without going through the planning process first.

In all of these cases and others both past and ongoing, there has been little effort to challenge the bald assertion that the pub is 'unviable', although CAMRA Kernow made a valiant attempt to stand up to the vested interests in the case of the Admiral Nelson.  However, we believe that, unless there is a clear case for allowing a pub to close for ever, if the locals want to keep it then hard questions should be asked and answers sought.  What it boils down to is this: if the licensees want to close a pub because (they say) it is not viable, is it because (a) the landlord is simply rubbish, or (b) the landlord wants to make a lot of money by selling it for development, or (c) the landlord simply want s to retire and turn the pub into a nice little des. res. worth much more on the housing market tan a licensed boozer?

The new Viability Test arms planners and the upset locals with some 50 questions to ask, probing whether in different hands the pub might be able to make money.  The most famous case in recent times is of course the Fountain Inn at Newbridge, which owners St. Austell Brewery condemned as a financial disaster and tried to turn into a country cottage.  The reason here was plainly case (a) above.  The locals aided by CAMRA fought it, then along came James and Daphne Pounder who agreed to take the pub on, and within a year or so it turned into one of the brewery's best accounts.  The rest, as they say, is history.

The questions to be asked in cases such as this include:

Population density - what is the pub's location in relation to the adult population, population density, nearby towns?
Visitor potential - is it in an attractive tourist area, in tourist guides, is it a focus for community activity?
Competition - How many other pubs in the area, is it different enough to cater for different groups of people to these?
Flexibility of site - could unused rooms or be brought into use, is there scope for extension?
Transport - how accessible is the pub, is there public transport, car parking space, has the pub advertised it?
Present business - what is the level of local support, could it be increased?

And so on.  The new test provides these and more guidelines, as well as case studies of real pubs, to help Local Authorities test objectively those claims of non-viability put forward by owners and developers.  More and more councils are waking up to the loss of public houses and are adopting policies to prevent their loss.  The test is not a back door attempt to ensure all pubs stay open, but it should help to ensure that potentially successful pubs are not lost for ever.

The new Public House Viability Test can be viewed at www.pubsweek.org - and guess who's on the front cover!


Top of Page Next story

Bert Dies

Long-standing CAMRA Kernow supporter and lover of real ale Bert Harley, of Hayle, has died after a long illness.

Aged 75, Bert was a well-known character on the pub circuit around his adopted home village of Crowlas.  His favourite beat was to visit the Mount View and Mexico Inns in Marazion on a Sunday lunchtime, then head back to Crowlas for another one or two in the Old Inn, and finally prepare himself for the Sunday dinner with arguably the best pint of the day, in the Star Inn at Crowlas.  However, he also seemed to manage a regular 'shopping' trip with his wife Margaret to Penzance, which seemed mainly to consist of her shopping and him waiting in the pub - the Peruvian seemed to be one of his regular haunts.

Bert was a Londoner through and through but loved Cornwall.  His rich accented voice crying, 'What the blahdy 'ell you doin' ere then?' if you walked in on him by surprise will be sadly missed.  We offer our deepest condolences to his wife Margaret and surviving family.


Bert discusses the finer points of real ale at the Celtic Beer Festival

Darren Norbury, editor of Beer Today, CAMRA Kernow and ale-drinking colleague at the Star Inn, adds:

'I think I can speak for all Star (Crowlas) regulars when I say that Saturday afternoons are not the 
same. On Saturday afternoons, Bert held court. He and Margaret would return from Penzance 
having invariably won a joint of meat at the weekly British Legion draw, and while Mrs H packed the 
shopping away Bert was trying whatever new brew had arrived since he was last in. A hearty slap 
on the back told you Bert had arrived - if you were a lady, a peck on the cheek was not unusual. His 
East London tones were unmistakable, but I'm sure he'd worked his way up to Honorary 
Cornishman level. The Mexico Inn at Long Rock and Penzance's London Inn, on Causewayhead, 
were other famous haunts, and in the spirit of not drink-driving he would often thumb a lift into town 
from outside the Star. Looking much younger than his 74 years, he was an effervescent character 
who would strike up a conversation with anyone, local or stranger - never happier than when 
nattering 18 to the dozen with a pint in his hand. He especially enjoyed his beer "fests", as he 
would always call them, and was a regular particularly at the St Ives CAMRA event - he enjoyed the 
atmosphere at the St Austell December festival too. Let's raise a glass to him.'


Top of Page Pub News

Cornish Pub News

West Cornwall

Locals in Cadgwith are up in arms about plans to turn their village pub, the Cadgwith Cove Inn, into a restaurant.  The pub acts as the social centre for the community, and is where local groups, societies and clubs frequently hold their meetings - there is no village hall.  Now the landlord claims that the premises are no longer financially viable as a pub and wants to go the whole hog and convert it into a full-on eating house.  Plans include building an extension, which is not seen as much of a problem by the villagers, but what has really upset them is the intention to strip out the inside to make it more open plan.  It seems the building is listed, both inside and out (it is 300 years old, has two separate rooms, rare enough in pubs these days, and is 'unspoilt'), so the licensee might have a battle with the planners on his hands.  He certainly will if the locals have anything to do with it - they are already preparing for the fight and have sought CAMRA advice (which has included using the new Public House Viability Test - see story above).  Unfortunately, with the law as it stands, the definition of Change of Use as considered by planning inspectors does not include a change from a pub to a restaurant, as they are considered as similar types of premises.  The locals will have to fight on other grounds, such as loss of amenity and preservation of a listed building, possibly citing the Cornwall County Plan.  An interesting development on the Lizard Peninsula - watch this space for further news.... 
UPDATE: A public meeting called for Thursday 17 March was held in the Gig Shed, to which representatives of Kerrier District Council and the pub owning company were invited.  The plans for redevelopment of the pub were subsequently rejected by the council planners, but of course the promoters have announced their intention to appeal.  Unfortunately, planning appeal decisions have an unhappy history as far as pub customers are concerned - the Admiral Nelson in Falmouth is one recent famous case in point.  We shall have to wait and see.

Shorts....... One of the county's more obscure pubs, the former Pendarves Arms at Gwithian (near Hayle), was been sold recently.  Re-christened the Red River Inn, it is a free house and seems to specialise in Sharp's ales at present although this has not always been the case.  Word is, it is about to be sold yet again in May, to the current barman whoi has promised to buy it when he has sold his house...... The oddly-named Flanagan's in Penzance is up for sale, as a leasehold property but advertised as 'free of tie', in other words it is a free house in pub terms.  It was once a Courage pub called the One & All, but the landlord changed it as he always wanted to run an Irish pub - so he said at the time!....  A pub which went the other way, converting back from an Irish theme bar two or three years back, is also on the market.  Now named the Clipper Bar, it started to sell real ale when it reverted, although availability is reported to have been sporadic. A free house, it's yours for £400,000.  Fancy a Camborne town centre pub, anyone?......  A familiar old pub on the Penzance-Helston road, the Lion & Lamb at Ashton, is also up for grabs as a £140,000 lease.  One of the many Devenish pubs asset-stripped away from the brewery by the Cannon revolution, it has been acquiring a name for a good selection of real ales of late.... In Devoran, the Old Quay is on the market again.  Owned by a pub chain and therefore limited in what it can buy, it nevertheless has a reputation for a decent pint and food.  Its sale follows after the sad death of the landlord last year...... The under-rated and undervisited (at least by CAMRA members) pub high over the north coast at Towan Cross near Porthtowan, the Victory Inn, is to be disposed of.  One of the precious stock of Cornish free houses, the asking price is £400,000.... Down in Falmouth, a relatively new establishment, the Waterfront Bar, is for sale.  Opened only a couple of years ago, it is as its name implies a seaside town bar rather than a pub, and attracts the younger element with its sometimes lively programme of entertainment.  Real ale is available, albeit a bit on the cold side in Lizard's experience..... The New Inn at Wendron has at last reopened having been taken by local people from the Falmouth area. This free house, which for some time has offered at least three decent real ales, has suffered several landlord changes in recent years, so making only sporadic appearances in the Good Beer Guide. It appears in the new 2005 edition, but the local CAMRA branch have decided to wait and see what happens before possibly removing it through an amendment.  There has been a fairly promising start, though; on the first night it was offering Tribute, Cornish Knocker and Betty Stogs, with a fourth handpump unused but waiting to see what the demand for real ale might be in the coming weeks.... The Mount's Bay Hotel in Mullion apparently suffered a sudden closure recently when, as a result it is thought of confusion caused by its proposed sale, the liquor licence ran out of date. It has been on the market for several months, as has another peninsula pub the Top House at The Lizard itself. They join a seemingly growing list of pubs for sale but apparently refusing to shift..... The well-known venue for jazz, the Smugglers' Inn at St. Erth Praze, is on the market again.  A free house, it underwent recent large scale refurbishment which at one time led to real ale being dispensed from polypins on the bar!  With two bars, a restaurant, function room and letting accommodation, it seems a bargain at £1 million.  Doesn't it?  Perhaps not...... 

Mid-Cornwall

Shorts....... One of central Cornwall's more well-known pubs, the Roseland Inn at Philleigh, is being sold leasehold at an asking price of £175,000.  As much of a restaurant as a pub, it nevertheless has managed to offer up to 4 real ales over the years including the rarely-seen (in Cornwall) Ringwood Best Bitter.  The owners recently moved to the Turk's Head in Penzance....  Skinner's Ale House in Newquay is on the march again.  Sold by Skinner's Brewery only a year or so again, it seems not to be working out as the then new owners intended.  Interesting to see if the Skinner's name - and the beers - continue to be associated with it when it goes to new licensees.  The asking price for the lease is £190,000.... In Cubert, developments at the Treetops Inn have infuriated locals.  The pub closed without warning the morning after a new year's party, and before the locals could draw breath the landlord had sold it for redevelopment. Recently, a planning application to turn it back into a dwelling refused.  A relatively recent conversion to a pub (about 30 years ago), the plan was to build 'affordable homes' on the car park as well. Failure to gain the necessary permission has not prevented the developers - or their shadowy agents - from appearing one day and knocking half the building down. It now stands semi-derelict, and its former customers can only stand by helpless while the battle is further engaged between the site owners and the planning authorities.....   In Truro, stories about the imminent appearance of J D Wetherspoon will not go away.  A report that a local newspaper had said they were going into the old West Briton newspaper offices on Lemon Quay remains however untraced and unconfirmed, although the rumour seems to have spread as far as CAMRA members in Bristol.  Despite assertions that the story is true we will continue to investigate; meanwhile, the Wetherspoon's answering machine is unable to comment at this time..... A new arrival on the estate agents' books in the city is the Globe Inn, leased from one of the major pub groups.  Run by one-time Trengilly Wartha landlord Huw Jones and his son Dylan, it has attempted to supplement the usual pub chain stuff with beers from Skinner's and Sharp's breweries, sold under gravity dispense from a stillage behind the bar.  The price for the lease is about £200,000....  Also in Truro, the White Hart (also for some reason calling itself the Crab & Ale House, though it doesn't sell the one and is not really the other) remains on the market, having been advertised since the autumn.  The lease is going for around £165,000.... The ancient and one-time Devenish pub the Miners' Arms at Mithian changed hands a few weeks ago......  And another former Devenish pub, the Falmouth Arms in Ladock, has appeared on the lists for disposal as a leasehold property for £100,000. 

East Cornwall

The Punch Bowl Inn at Lanreath, not far from Looe, is up for sale, the asking price for the lease being £100,000.... And a rush of sales coming up in Liskeard: the Red Lion, a small town centre free house (although a leasehold property) is being advertised at £25,000 for the lease.  In the same town, the White Horse, the Albion and the Fountain are all reportedly being considered for sale, and even the Old Stag by the station is said to be on the list, although these last few are not yet confirmed.  We will update as more information comes to hand... A bit further west, the well-known real ale pub in Lostwithiel the Royal Oak is to be sold, at no less than £1,000,000.  Admittedly this is a large pub by anyone's standards having as it does 6 letting rooms, 2 bars, function room and all the rest of it.  It has over the years proved a staunch supporter of beers from the nearby Keltek Brewery.

North Cornwall

The Old Wainhouse Inn at Wainhouse Corner near Bude is on the market.  A frequent entry in the Good Beer Guide, the asking price for this free house is £700,000.... Also, the King Arthur's Arms at Tintagel has appeared on the lists, and is apparently already under offer....... The Maltsters Arms at Chapel Amble near Wadebridge is being advertised for sale, but is being promoted more as a restaurant than a pub.....

(Sources: CAMRA members, Beer Today, Packet Newspapers, the West Briton and allied publications, pub gossip, Scilly locals and Lizard's beer-stained notebook).  And One & Ale!


Top of Page Brewery News

Cornish Brewery News

In Stithians, the newly-installed tiny Bathtub Brewery ('nano-brewery' according to its head brewer) has started regular brewing on site.  Some experimental brews have already appeared over the bar in the village pub, and following the success of Pete's Porter a premium bitter called Stithians Special has been developed.  Based on an earlier trial version called Wasted which made its debut at the pub in September, it has been through several iterations (via, recently, a 'Wasted Version 2.2'), to its current incarnation, slightly weaker, at 4.7% abv.

spacerThe newly-revivified Wooden Hand Brewery at Grampound Road goes from strength to strength, has added a fourth beer to their portfolio.  Called Cornish Buccaneer,  it is a 4.3% abv brew .  The other three beers produced by ex-Redruth Brewery employees Kevin Frantham and Mel Hill are Cornish Mutiny (4.8%abv, their first brew), Smugglers' Gold, a lighter beer at 3.6%abv that has sold well in spite of limited fine weather; and Black Pearl (4.3%), not a dark beer as its name implies but a best bitter aimed at the likes of Doom Bar and Betty Stogs drinkers.  The brewery's premises, the original Ventonwyn Brewery site, was too cramped for everything that Kev and Mel want to do, so they recently acquired another industrial unit close by where they can store the beer for maturing.

spacerSharp's Brewery has been going all out recently to expand its operation both within the county and beyond.  Sales have gone up 30% during the autumn quarter of 2004 compared with the same period in 2003, presumably as a result of their new sales team operating all over the south-west, as far up as Swindon  so far.  The brewery has installed 6 new fermenters, and plan to have doubled plant capacity to 100 barrels by this time next year with further work planned for the winter months.

spacerSkinner's Brewery in Truro are now looking to take forward plans to instal two more fermenters in the brewhouse.  This will be the first stage in a move into keg lager to satisfy the demands of the surfing fraternity.  It has made the occasional appearance in cask form as Cornish Storm, but the plant looks likely to handle a keg version of Pennycomequick Stout as well, which may rival Guinness in some of the local pubs.

spacerSt. Austell Brewery  are planning to brew Admiral's Ale again after a long period of absence and its successful appearance at Falmouth beer festival; the plan is to sell it in bottled form to be launched before Easter, but with a cask-conditioned draught version available on a seasonal basis, in the summer.  Its strength is 5.0%abv.

spacerThe Driftwood Spars Brewery recently stopped dry-hopping its Cuckoo Ale, which has reportedly improved the flavour.  Keltek Brewery continues to be very busy, selling everything it can brew as well as being kept busy bottling the Spingo range for the Blue Anchor in Helston and other brewers in the county and beyond.  Keltek have also initiated a serious expansion on their Lostwithiel site, with new fermenters installed to increase their brewing capacity to a massive 20 barrels from two and a half. Not all of this will be used immediately however, which will allow some capacity for experimental brewing.  Blackawton Brewery in Saltash is continuing production of the beers as before despite being sold to new owners in the autumn.  Last but not least, Doghouse Brewery reported brisk sales of Staffi Stout, competing well with Guinness since the prices of the latter in Cornwall started to reach near rip-off levels.  And - at last - a name has been decided for the long-awaited brew using the new Susan hops.  It is called Snoozy Suzy, and has been generating a strong demand.  Its strength is 4.3%abv.


Top of Page Pubs Diary

Pubs Diary

Welcome to our feature, the Cornish Pubs Diary. The idea is that anything to do with the promotion of real ale by our local landlords will warrant an entry here. Events will mostly take the form of beer festivals no doubt, but with a growing fund of experience in this field and their growing popularity, we feel that some central listing is useful - which also helps landlords to avoid clashes! Do let us know of any planned real ale events at your local boozer. For further details of pub festivals, go to our beer festival page.

Inclusive Dates Venue Event
15-17 April Red Lion Inn, Newquay 2nd Annual Beer Festival
29 April-1 May Smugglers' Den, Trebellan Ale & Pie Festival (for bus details see below)
29 April-1 May Widemouth Manor, Widemouth Bay Beer festival: 30+ ales from Cornwall & beyond
1-31 May Blisland Inn, Blisland Mad Mild Month - 50+ milds spread over May
17-19 June Old Court House, Mawgan Real ale festival (Cornish ales)
23 July Three Tuns, St. Keverne One day beerfest coinciding with the town carnival - 8 beers outside the pub, 3 as usual inside
(all events subject to confirmation - check if in doubt)

NB : The Smugglers' Den are laying on bus transport on Saturday 30 April as follows:

Falmouth (outside Argos store): 10.30 (return 19.00)
Truro (King William IV pub):    11.00 (return 18.30)
Newquay (Manor Rd bus station): 12.00 (return 18.00)


Top of Page Next article

Cornish Ale Guide On Sale

spacerThis is the definitive guide to real ale in Cornwall - and it is on sale now, with recent updates included.

spacerMembers of Cornwall CAMRA spent no less than 12 months researching every one (we hope) of the county's pubs, sampling the ale, and writing about it in order to bring you the most comprehensive guide to date. Every known real ale pub has been listed in standard Good Beer Guide format, and the ones which don't have any also get a mention, so that you don't have to waste time going through the door (and in the hope that they may change their policy in future).  AND we are not standing still.  Research is continuous, so every so often we can bring the listings up to date, even if the cover still looks the same.

spacerBecause we are such a large county, the Guide has been divided into 5 geographical areas for convenience - north, east, mid-Cornwall, west, and Scilly. This keeps nearby pubs grouped together in the book and should make it easier to refer to. Street maps are provided for the bigger towns, and all of Cornwall's 13 breweries - including the newest on the Isles of Scilly - are listed with a description of the beers they produce.

spacerDue to the lack of public transport in some areas, willing driving partners and the foot & mouth epidemic (one of our busiest researchers is a ministry vet!), as well as everyone being volunteers with other jobs to do, it took us longer than anticipated to get the thing published. However, the means are now in place to update it easily, and we are now able quickly to produce updated editions from time to time.

spacerWant a copy? Of course you do. It is available by post to UK CAMRA members for £5.00 including the stamp (quote your membership number) or £5.80 to non-CAMRA members. Send cheques (made payable to Cornwall CAMRA) to editor Steve Willmott - see Contacts list for address details. Or we'll take €10.


Top of Page One & Ale

One & Ale - the Cornwall CAMRA Newsletter

spacerIn common with the other branches of CAMRA, the Cornwall branch produces its own hard-copy newsletter, One & Ale. It appears about 5 times a year, at slightly irregular intervals because it may be timed to coincide with the major events such as the local beer festivals. It is aimed both at the branch membership, who are widely scattered around the county and each get a copy through the post, and non-members who may pick it up to read in selected pubs.

spacerOne & Ale contains news of breweries, brews and pubs in the county, as well as views and reports of pub crawls and the like written by the branch members. As a free publication, its only source of funding is its advertising income, which is of course to an extent dependent on how interesting the contents are. We are always looking for reports or articles from CAMRA members, and new contributors are especially welcome. Copy should be submitted to Steve Willmott, who is also the Editor and Distribution Manager (see Contacts page). If it is a word processor file and sent on a floppy disk, it's even more welcome!

spacerSome earlier editions of One & Ale On-line can be seen in our archive. Just click on the one you want to see:

January-February 2004 
March-April 2004 
May-June 2004 
July-August 2004 
September-October 2004 
November-December 2004 
January-February 2005 

spacerThe views expressed in these pages are of course those of the authors, and not necessarily of CAMRA Ltd or the Cornwall Branch of CAMRA.


Top of Page